Which of the two rums, Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum or Captain Morgan, is the more flavorful, and what distinguishes one from the other?
Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum vs Captain Morgan
The Captain Morgan Spiced rum has a solid bite, followed by sweet caramel and vanilla. The flavour stays around the throat, leaving the drinker satisfied.
On the other hand, Sailor Jerry is less sweet and spicier than Captain Morgan. It has a strong dose of bold cloves and cinnamon that dissipates quickly, leaving you wanting more.
Below are in-depth examinations of their differences to help you determine which is best suited to your preferences.
How These Two Get Produced: Behind The Scene
Sailor Jerry is from the New Jersey, United States. It is the best dark rums, bottled at 92 proof and made by old-school methods with an expert blend of spices to ensure perfect balance.
Captain Morgan Spiced Rum is manufactured from the constant distillation. The golden colour is the result of the ageing process. After that, it’s matured for a year or more in oak barrels before being spiced and flavoured.
On the other side, Sailor Jerry contains a pleasant taste of spiciness with cinnamon and a hint of vanilla.
Captain Morgan is a mix of various Caribbean rums, vanilla, and caramel that makes it sweeter than Sailor Jerry.
The Details
Alcohol Volume (ABV in %)
- Sailor Jerry Spiced Rum Alcohol Percentage: 46%.
- Captain Morgan Alcohol Percentage: 35%
Colour
Both rums look identical without their labelling. The only noticeable difference is the dark luminance of yellow colour is higher in Captain Morgan.
Taste
Sailor Jerry spiced rum has a strong and spicy flavour and a creamy and smooth flavour with overtones of vanilla and cinnamon.
On the other hand, Captain Morgan is medium-bodied, smooth, and sweeter, with hints of vanilla and caramel.
Flavour
FlavourCaptain Morgan’s flavour and finish are classic. It has distinct rum cocktail flavours.
On the other hand, Sailor Jerry has a nicely balanced oak and vanilla flavour with undertones of cloves, cinnamon, and other spices.
Price
Price will vary depending on the region; at Pakuranga Liquor Spot, you can buy Sailor Jerry spiced rum 700ml for $59.99 and Captain Morgan (1-litre) for $48.99.
Verdict
There is no way to answer which is better than the other as both brands have their uniqueness and charm that sets them apart.
However, considering their features, we can say that Sailor Jerry rums are best for people who prefer spice and punch, while Captain Morgan rums are best for celebrations and for people who like sweeter rums.
